c.1890 New York Victorian Farmhouse For Sale on 5.18 Acres $259,900

$259,900

Authentic 19th-century character meets expansive country living! Nestled on 5+ private, picturesque acres, this grand 1890 New York victorian farmhouse boasts over 2,900 square feet of timeless living space. From stunning original woodwork and gleaming hardwood floors to the cozy wood stove, every detail preserves the home’s historic soul while offering generous room for family and guests across 5 bedrooms.

Realtor Comments

Many of the windows have been updated, and the roof is approximately 15 years old, providing added peace of mind. Outside, you’ll find a detached 2-car garage, mature apple trees, and mowed walking paths that invite you to explore and enjoy your own private slice of the countryside. Whether you’re looking for room to grow, a hobby farm, or simply a peaceful rural retreat, this property offers timeless character, abundant space, and endless possibilities. Call today for your appointment!

More New York Properties

5bd
1.5ba
2,979sqft
5.18 acres
Circa 1890

Contact Realtor: Karen E Cammarata, Abr, Rsps
Brokered by Howard Hanna
Google Maps
Niche

Pros

Exceptional Land Value & Low Housing Costs: Real estate and acreage are significantly more affordable than downstate New York or larger regional hubs. It is an attractive spot for buyers looking for acreage, hunting cabins, or budget-friendly country living.
Massive Outdoor & Recreational Access: The town is dominated by thousands of acres of public land, including McDonough State Forest and Bowman Lake State Park. It’s a haven for outdoor enthusiasts interested in hunting, hiking (the Finger Lakes Trail passes through), snowmobiling, fishing, and camping.
Seclusion, Space, and Privacy: Properties in McDonough are largely spread out over generous acreage. With virtually no industrial hubs or heavy traffic, the area provides a peaceful, quiet, slow-paced lifestyle.
Extremely Low Crime Rates: With very low population density and an isolated rural footprint, local crime rates are well below national and state averages.
Quaint Local Heritage: The town has a close-knit, historic feel—featuring the famous living 115-foot Norway spruce Christmas tree (a town tradition since 1927) and a historic town library housed in a restored 19th-century chapel.

Cons

Virtually No In-Town Commercial Amenities: McDonough has almost no retail or commercial infrastructure beyond a post office, fire department, and town park. Grocery shopping, pharmacies, and standard household errands require driving roughly 15 miles (20+ minutes) to Norwich or Oxford.
Very Limited Local Job Market: Economic opportunities in the immediate town limits are nearly non-existent. Most residents commute to larger regional centers (like Norwich, Cortland, or Binghamton) or work remotely.
Long, Heavy Winters: Located in Central NY, winters are cold, snowy, and long. Snowmobiling is popular, but navigating winding rural backroads during lake-effect snowstorms requires reliable 4WD/AWD vehicles and winter prep.
Distance to Healthcare & Higher Services: Urgent medical needs or specialized care require traveling to regional hospital systems in Norwich (UHS Chenango Memorial) or larger networks in Binghamton and Syracuse.
Spotty Rural Infrastructure: High-speed internet (broadband) availability and cellular coverage can vary depending on where a home sits relative to local ridges and hollows.