Back on the Market! c.1890 Former Captain Mey's Inn For Sale in NJ Under $5M

OHC Notes $4,950,000 – Relisted $4,490,000

Former Captain May’s Inn is back on the market! Is it because it may be a money pit, or is it the history?

House View featured at 202 Ocean St, Cape May, NJ, 08204

Realtor Comments

Dont miss this opportunity to own a piece of Cape May history. Currently operated as the Captain Mey’s Inn, this turn of the century Victorian home, circa 1890 was built by Dr. Walter Phillips. The corner location just steps to both the mall and beaches of Cape May make this the best location to enjoy all that the wonderful town has to offer. Make it your own as either a single family property or maintain the B&B license and continue it as your new creation.

Interior

Painstakingly renovated and update while respecting its heritage and original character this 13 bedroom, 11 bath home boasts large scale rooms, elegant detailing and beautiful woodwork throughout. Step onto the front porch that wraps around onto tree lined Hughes Street. The 1st room upon entry is the Office Quarters (named for the Doctors visiting room). A large ornate hallway leads to the beautiful living room (parlor) and connects to the fabulous dining room. Down the hall is the highly desirable Captains Quarters with private bath and side entrance. Step into the hall bath and head back towards the spacious kitchen, laundry room with steps to the off street parking spot, and the utility room with steps to the private 40 x 100 parking lot. The 2nd level is home to 4 bedrooms with private baths and a 5th bedroom with a hall bath. The spacious hallway takes you to the 3rd floor lading with fire escape. The 3rd level is home to 2 large bedrooms with private baths that have whirlpool tubs. The owners quarters are in the lower level and offer a living room, kitchen, 4 bedrooms and 2 baths with an exterior and interior entrance.

Additional

Amenities include a new roof, recently stained wood siding, numerous stained glass pieces that have been restored, oak and pine floors, new gas HWH, pecks plumbing, Shores security system and a State Fire Inspection. The parking lot owned as a separate parcel offers 8 parking spots and a picnic area. The brick sidewalk adds that last touch of beauty! Showings by appointment only due to a working business.