c.1895 New Jersey Victorian For Sale $2,695,000

new jersey victorian

$2,695,000

For the first time in decades, a true New Jersey Victorian treasure has emerged in the heart of historic Cape May. Perfectly positioned between the sun-drenched Atlantic shoreline and the vibrant Washington Street Mall, this breathtaking 6-bedroom, 3-bath residence stands as one of the most storied and picturesque homes in the city. Don’t miss this rare opportunity to own a landmark property that captures the timeless elegance and coastal charm of Cape May at its very finest.
view 1st full size image of this home

Realtor Comments

Step onto the adorable front porch and feel the “super energy” that only a prime in-town location can deliver. Walk everywhere – beaches, restaurants, shops, theaters, and every attraction Cape May has to offer are literally steps from your door. A rare rear porch overlooks the private backyard, ideal for morning coffee or evening entertaining. Inside, the home showcases stunning period architecture highlighted by a commanding turret, intricate millwork, original hardwood floors, and oversized windows that flood every room with light. The layout is perfect for both grand family gatherings and comfortable everyday living. This is a true legacy property – lovingly maintained yet untouched by the market for decades. Whether you’re seeking a spectacular second home to create lifelong memories or a turn-key investment property with amazing rental income potential in America’s oldest seaside resort, this is the one you’ve been waiting for. Cape May’s most desirable location + unmatched curb appeal + rare availability = an opportunity that will not last.
view 2nd full size image of this home
  • 6bed
  • 3bath
  • Circa 1895
view 3rd full size image of this home
view 4th full size image of this home

Pros

  • Exceptional Quality of Life: Residents enjoy a serene, historic environment with well-maintained streets, clean beaches, and a picturesque aesthetic. It offers a sophisticated lifestyle prioritizing fine dining, arts, and environmental stewardship.

     

  • Strong Sense of Community: Despite the seasonal influx, there is a dedicated year-round population. Locals describe a friendly, hospitable atmosphere where citizens are actively involved in town governance and historic preservation.

     

  • Walkability & Lifestyle: The historic district is highly walkable, with easy access to the Washington Street Mall, local boutiques, and various culinary spots. Biking is a preferred mode of transport for many locals.

     

  • Natural Beauty & Recreation: Beyond the beach, the area is world-renowned for birding, nature trails, kayaking in back-bay marshes, and scenic parks.

     

  • Safety: It is generally considered a safe, family-friendly environment compared to larger urban hubs.

     

Cons

  • Seasonal Volatility: As a major tourist resort, the town’s population increases dramatically in the summer. This leads to traffic congestion and a complete shift in pace between the busy season and the quieter winter months.

     

  • Economic & Job Limitations: The local economy is heavily dependent on tourism, which can result in a lack of professional, year-round job opportunities. Many businesses operate seasonally, leading to periods of reduced activity.

     

  • Cost of Living: Housing is expensive, and finding suitable year-round rentals can be difficult due to the high demand for seasonal/vacation properties.

  • Limited Retail & Amenities: Outside of the summer peak, some retail and dining options close or have reduced hours. For specialized shopping or diverse large-scale commercial services, residents often have to travel significantly further.

     

  • Socioeconomic Challenges: Like many historic areas, behind the picturesque facade, the region faces challenges related to poverty, income inequality, and, as noted in some community feedback, social issues that residents must navigate.

view 5th full size image of this home

130 Decatur St, Cape May, NJ 08204

view 6th full size image of this home
*
view 7th full size image of this home
*
view 8th full size image of this home
*
view 9th full size image of this home
*
view 10th full size image of this home
*
view 11th full size image of this home
*
view 12th full size image of this home
*
view 13th full size image of this home
*
view 14th full size image of this home
*
view 15th full size image of this home
*
view 16th full size image of this home
*
view 17th full size image of this home
*
view 18th full size image of this home
*
view 19th full size image of this home
*
view 20th full size image of this home
*
view 21st full size image of this home
*
view 22nd full size image of this home
*
view 23rd full size image of this home
*
view 24th full size image of this home
*
view 25th full size image of this home
*
view 26th full size image of this home
*
view 27th full size image of this home
*
view 28th full size image of this home
*
view 29th full size image of this home
*
view 30th full size image of this home
*
view 31st full size image of this home
*
view 32nd full size image of this home
*
view 33rd full size image of this home
*
view 34th full size image of this home
*
view 35th full size image of this home
*
view 36th full size image of this home
*
view 37th full size image of this home
*
view 38th full size image of this home
*
view 39th full size image of this home
*
view 40th full size image of this home
*
view 41st full size image of this home
*
view 42nd full size image of this home
*
view 43rd full size image of this home
*
view 44th full size image of this home
*
view 45th full size image of this home
*
view 46th full size image of this home
*
view 47th full size image of this home
*
view 48th full size image of this home
*
view 49th full size image of this home
*